Bill Schindler: What He Actually Ate in a Blue Zone, and Why We Need to Process Food

Archaeologist Bill Schindler lived with a family in Sardinia's Blue Zone. He says the meals there were mostly animal foods and fermented dairy. Here's what he saw and how to remove a link from your food chain.

By Harry Gray · Nov 4, 2026 · 4 min read

By The Meat Mafia (Harry Gray and Brett Ender)

Bill Schindler finally got his invitation after years of trying. A family in Sardinia agreed to show him how they still prepared a traditional food. When he arrived, he realized where he was: Villagrande, which he calls the epicenter of the first Blue Zone ever identified.

He'd seen the Netflix version of Blue Zones. What he ate at the family table looked very different.

Every meal, he told us, was built on the animal, every part of it, with plenty of fermented dairy. There were few vegetables, and the family grew any they did have themselves.

Somebody at the table had raised, slaughtered and butchered nearly everything on it. The only exception at one multi-hour meal was the wine, and a relative had made that.

Then there was the walking. The village sits on a mountainside. His neighbor was 103, lived on the second floor and climbed the stairs by himself every day. Exhausted after the drive, Bill's group was invited straight out on a walk.

When he asked what the secret was, he got the same answer every time: we're nice to each other.

That trip fits Bill's bigger idea. As an archaeologist, he studies how our ancestors used tools and fire to make food safer and more nutritious. He believes we still depend on processing for almost everything we eat.

"animals will kill you when they're alive and plants will kill you when they're dead" (14:00)

He doesn't think you need to change everything overnight. His approach is smaller and simpler.

"Remove a link from your food chain, whatever that happens to be." (32:00)

Listen to the full episode · Watch on YouTube

TL;DR: Bill Schindler, an archaeologist, says humans have relied on technology to process food for a very long time, and that almost everything we eat today still needs processing to be safe and nutritious. He visited Villagrande in Sardinia, which he calls the epicenter of the first Blue Zone. There, he says, meals were built on the whole animal and fermented dairy, every ingredient came from someone at the table, and when he asked about the secret, people said they were kind to each other. His advice: remove one link from your food chain at a time. His views, not medical advice.

Who is Bill Schindler? An archaeologist and anthropologist, author of Eat Like a Human, and co-owner of the Modern Stone Age Kitchen restaurant in Chestertown, Maryland.

Key takeaways

Bill believes we need processing for almost every food we eat today (08:00).
He says hunting gave our ancestors access to the most nutrient-dense parts of the animal (13:00).
His rule at the restaurant: no two ingredients combined outside its walls (05:00, 42:00).
He has made every loaf of bread his kids eat, as wild, long-fermented sourdough (32:00–33:00).
In Villagrande, he says, meals were the whole animal and fermented dairy (46:00).

Why processing matters

Bill's view is that our big brains need dense, bioavailable nutrition and our guts aren't built to get it all from raw food. Our ancestors solved that with tools, fire and fermentation. The problem today, he says, isn't processing itself but how industrial food is processed.

Plants versus animals

He says animal foods are hard to get but easy to make safe, and plants are the opposite: easy to gather, with the real work afterward to detoxify them. He still enjoys some plants, like Brussels sprouts fried in lard with bacon, when they're prepared properly.

What he saw in the Blue Zone

In Villagrande he saw very old people who were active, walking hills every day, eating food raised by the family and treating each other kindly. He believes the food story told on TV left out the animal foods he saw on the table. That's his first-hand account from one village.

Remove a link from your food chain

His practical advice: take one step closer to your food. If you buy chicken breasts, buy a whole chicken. If you already do, buy it from a farmer. Small changes, repeated for years, add up, like the bread he bakes for his kids.

FAQ

Who is Bill Schindler? An archaeologist and anthropologist, author of Eat Like a Human, and co-owner of the Modern Stone Age Kitchen in Chestertown, Maryland.

What did Bill Schindler eat in the Blue Zone? In Villagrande, Sardinia, he says meals were built on the whole animal and fermented dairy, with few vegetables (~42:00–46:00).

What does remove a link from your food chain mean? Take one step closer to the source, like swapping chicken breasts for a whole chicken, then buying from a farm (~32:00).

Does Bill Schindler say to avoid plants? No. He says plants need careful preparation to be safe and nutritious, and he enjoys some when they're cooked properly (~17:00, ~21:00).

Get the free guide: 100 Books to Transform Your Health. Join the Meat Mafia email list and we'll send it to you.

Not medical advice. This post summarizes a podcast conversation for education. The views are the guest's own. Talk to a qualified clinician before you change your diet, supplements or any medication.